28 Responses

1. Readers,

   What would you say for “why our 12-week old puppy died”? Pick any one or add your own answer:

   1) Puppy will be buried but later Allah will come with 72 virgins for the puppy.

   2) On the Judgment Day, Jesus will take the puppy to heaven to meet God.

   3) The puppy will be incarnated to Ami.

   4) Like Jewish would say, we don’t know.

   Reply

   1. admin, you have again fabricated teachings of Islam, where do you get the concept of 72 virgin.

      Reply

      1. In Islam, the concept of 72 virgins (houri) refers to an aspect of Jannah (Paradise). This concept is grounded in Qur’anic text which describe a sensual Paradise where believing men are rewarded by being wed to virgins with “full grown”, “swelling” or “pears-shaped” breasts. Conversly, women will be provided with only one man, and they “will be satisfied with him”.

         Hadith collections:
         Sunan Ibn Majah, one of the six major Hadith collections, it states in a hasan (good) narration that every male admitted into Paradise will be given eternal erections and wed to 72 wives, all with libidinous sex organs. Similarly in another hadith with multiple narrators that has been graded hasan (good), it states that the martyr (shahid) will be married to seventy-two of al-hoor al-‘iyn.

         In the Sunan al-Tirmidhi, another of the six major Hadith collections, it states that the smallest reward for the people of Heaven is an abode with 72 houri.

         Also reported in Sunan al-Kubra and Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and declared sahih (authentic) by Ibn Abi Shayba, Ibn Hibban, and al-Hakim is the hadith that states the servant in Paradise will be married with 70 wives and that they’ll be given the sexual strength for a hundred.

         Orthodox Muslim theologians have related further hadith that give us the exact number of 72, such as al-Ghazali who wrote, “[The Prophet said] the lowest rank of an inmate of Paradise will have eighty thousand servants and seventy two wives.”

         mac, do you wish us to fully narrate details in a separate post, let us know. This is something you should know what you are going to get on the Judgement Day.

         Reply

         1. I want to clap u admin…u are doing great job that copying and pasting from anti islamic sites that even not proven correctly..

            The comment which you have posted from wikiislam.net which is no1 anti islamic site
            even though u didnt give any refrence that what are you telling is not proved is 1% correct

            Is this ur respect to islamic faith admin?

            Here is the source
            http://wikiislam.net/wiki/72_Virgins

            click here to understand correctly about hoor

            Reply

            1. From the site you suggested states “In the Quran the houris are called “companions”, described as being “restraining in their glances (chaste)”, with “modest gazes”, “wide and beautiful/lovely eyes”, “eyes like pearls”, “splendid”, “voluptuous” and “large-breasted”.” Is Koran talking about raisins or girls? How many are you expecting, 2 or 20 or 72?

               Is there any chance that Ami and her no-more-Muslim husband make to heaven one day?

2. I personally don’t feel that being atheist is a good way to live as you cannot prove that God exist but it cannot be disproved either..But hey, whatever floats your boat. ..you’re happy with it and that’s enough

   Reply

3. Exam near door, otherwise I would have thoroughly debated on atheism and islam, i debate with atheist, its better to debate with atheist than with a christian, because an atheist is open minded where as a christian will close his eye and will not accept truth, same way, Hindus are much open minded compared to Christians.

   Reply

   1. …. and most Muslims are very close minded. It is hard to work with them.

      Focus on your studies, that is a priority for you now.

      As we have always said, when you will reach 40, you will become a pluralist like Iftekhar Hai (and start respecting all faiths and beliefs, even remain a proud Muslim).

      Reply

      1. I do respect all faiths, going through this website, any liberal,open minded people can realize who are close minded, Muslims or Hindus. Last day I saw video where Hindu extremist forced a muslim guy to worship a monkey, recently ban on beef in India, not allowing non-Brahmins in the kitchen, not allowing fellow Hindus who are not higher caste by birth in the kitchen room, list goes on, Yes you are open minded but only in media not real life, Think what I said above.

         Reply

      2. Dear admin,

         we respect to each faith and every religion people..They are not our enemy….but they are doing greatest sin(shirk) with the god almighty with associating patners with almighty.. so beliving their faith is impossible to us and Allah says in the Quran on various places that i will forgive all the sins except shirk(i.e, the topest sin). . and those who associate patners surely(Guarenteed) they will go to hell because they are doing injustice to the Allah almighty..
         All the messangers which have camed in this earth has delivered the same message (la ilaha illalla i.e., That there is not god except Allah. . nothing like unto him he is greatest from all the Things)

         Allah says in the Quran
         in surah nisa chapter 4 verse 48
         “Indeed, Allah does not forgive association with Him, but He forgives what is less than that for whom He wills. And he who associates others
         with Allah has certainly fabricated a tremendous sin.”

         we respect their faith not like you admin.. .you have posted several things against islam and prophet mohammed(p.b.u.h) which is not a correct. . you hav understand islam wrongly but we didnt post any single comment which is against on their faith. . firstly u need to respect islam

         our beloved prophet (p.b.u.h) said
         “Who so ever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart — and that is the weakest of faith.”[Muslim]

         This is an important hadith because it shows that Muslims should not be innocent bystanders – we are obliged to do something to stop wrong doing. It also outlines to us the order in which
         we must do something.

         If they didnt understand what we are saying atleast we curse in our heart that people are not wrong but their act is wrong. .

         Reply

      3. Thanks Mohammed bro, i didn`t knew that hadith.

         Reply

4. The dream that motivates the most is the promise of 72 virgin wives after death in paradise, in case a devout Muslim lives as per the tenets and philosophy of Islam. These 72 virgins belief is mentioned in the Koran and further elucidated in the Hadiths. Young boys are enamored of this and willingly sacrifice their life as a suicide bomber.
   Suicide bombers are in every religion, but in 9 cases out of 10 they profess the Islamic faith. This is the harsh fact of life and cannot be negated. Recently a couple of young boys were arrested in England, who confessed that they were being trained as suicide bombers. These boys also informed that they expected to get 72 virgin wives after death.

   Reply

   1. so

      Reply

5. Dear amit tajudden,

   The three most important questions to ask in life:
   1. How did I get here?
   2. Why am I here?
   3. Where am I going?
   The answers are all found in Islam.

   Reply

6. Hi,

   Feels good to know that there are a few people out there who value happiness and love in a relationship over everything else. After all, what’s life without happiness, love and positivity? Unfortunately, in case of inter faith marriages a lot of precious time is wasted in doubt, uncertainty and disputes among loved ones.

   A simple fact here, love is not calculated. It is not manipulative and does not seek sacrifice. I’m glad that Ami, being so well educated, took a decision of turning to atheism and being happy about it. I have scientist parents who are liberal Hindus, but who will definitely oppose my relationship with my Muslim boyfriend of 10years. I am financially independent and so is my boyfriend. However, his parents want me to convert. I’m not being arrogant about my education or family background here, but I am vehemently against religious conversion. I know its not easy..but if you can fall in love and pursue a Hindu girl, then you better find the courage to marry the Hindu girl.

   I know and believe that I will give his family the same (or maybe even more) love, respect and care that any Muslim girl might give them (apart from keeping their son happy). But sadly, that is not enough.

   We are currently devising ways to convince his parents to accept me as a Hindu. This point we plan to use to convince my parents too.

   I welcome suggestions from anybody who has something constructive to offer. I do not want to know that Islam doesn’t permit it..everybody knows it. I have fallen into this with eyes open so yes I know about it.

   Reply at http://www.interfaithshaadi.org/?p=9702

   Reply

7. I used to be a good Muslim until I grew up and searched for the truth. I learnt a lot about Islam as I’m in the most populated Islamic country. Thanks to the internet I found many facts against what I have been previously taught before by Islamic scholars. I found that Islam is full of fallacies and leads to insane and satanic behavior, really inhumane and crazy. Then I started thinking and decided that everyone is born as an atheist. I do hope that god exists but I can’t deny that god is not, well, at least I don’t have the proof so else millions like me. So I will just keep my eyes of mind open to think and live my life free from burden dogmas. Thanks to WikiIslam and all atheists, agnostics, and secular humanists for keeping up the fight against terrorism and educating those who are blinded by faith.

   Gon Candu, 33, Indonesia, now an atheist

   Reply

   1. You did a good copy paste

      Proof

      Reply

8. When my in-laws asked me to convert to islam in order to marry, I refused but only after doing my best to find the universal truth. I travelled to Jerusalem even. All I found in that intense search was that none of them offer a real purpose to our existence. They only provide teaching on how to live your life, not why you have life in the first place. For me, there is no other question more important than our purpose here. Everything else falls into place after that is answered.

   Determining which one of the many is the truth invariably ends up in a mud-slinging dialogue because the truth is they are all false. Still, at the time of our marriage, we were both believers, I a hindu and him a muslim.

   There was no convincing my husband’s parents. Naufel had already decided, asking me was just a courtesy to them. It was then their decision whether they wanted to be a part of our lives or not. They wanted to stick by their son even if they felt he was making the wrong decision.

   As an aside, I will admit. Mixed with typical in-law strife, I have never been able to fully look past that initial rejection and despite the awareness of it, I believe it subconsciously affects our relationship to this day.

   I remember meeting the imam ahead of time. I can’t say what made him agree to perform a nikkah, but for the right price, he did. I had been in contact with another couple like ourselves and 2 years later I provided his contact details for them and unfortunately, the imam refused to perform that nikkah.

   We live in the US. I never recited the shahadah. My husband left islam publicly in 2010. It was tough for his mother especially. According to islam she had failed in her single duty in this life. She will not see him or her granddaughters in the heaven she thinks she’ll one day go to. it has forced her (them) to enjoy the moments we have together now. For the first time in 60 years she put on a bathing suit and swam in the ocean here in beautiful Hawaii with her legacy. It doesn’t get any more beautifully real than that.

   All my best,
   -Smita

   Reply

9. Admin, scientist are not the author of logic. I can show you beliefs of scientific community of 100 years ago, those beliefs are today regarded as ridiculous, but scientist of those eras believed those jokes as fact. E.g: Sun is stationary, Moon came from Ocean.
   But today we know sun is not stationary but rotates about its own axis and its rotational period is 25 days. And Quran in 7th century said the same thing that sun is not stationary but has rotational motion.If any scientific person in 20th century said that sun is stationary and a muslim said that “no, sun is not stationary but rotates”, then that atheistic person would have won the debate siting science but today no atheist will think about it, they will laugh if anyone say sun is stationary about its own axis.

   Even a kid will laugh at you if you say moon came from ocean, but this is what scientist had believed not many years ago. Actually we can clearly see atheist are in better position in this 21st century as science has advanced so much. But what would have been their argument 100 years ago..anyway whatever may be the scientific advancement, not a single scientific FACT is against Quran

   Until the dawn of the 20th century, the only view prevailing in the world of science was that “the universe has a constant nature and it has existed since infinite time.” However, modern research, observations, and calculations carried out by means of modern technology have revealed that the universe in fact had a beginning and that it constantly “expands.”

   At the beginning of the 20th century, the Russian physicist Alexander Friedmann and the Belgian cosmologist Georges Lemaitre theoretically calculated that the universe is in constant motion and that it is expanding.

   From the moment of the Big Bang, the universe has been constantly expanding at a great speed. Scientists compare the expanding universe to the surface of a balloon that is inflated.

   This notion was confirmed by the use of observational data in 1929. While observing the sky with a telescope, Edwin Hubble, the American astronomer, discovered that the stars and galaxies were constantly moving away from each other. This discovery is regarded as one of the greatest in the history of astronomy.

   But Quran in 7th century said the same thing,(Quran 51:47)which is been discovered in recent centuries using highly sophisticated scientific equipments, but question is how Quran knows all these things. Only answer is that Quran is the word of the creator(GOD/ALLAH/BHAGWAN), the creator knows how he created the earth,universe , so the creator(Allah) easily said these things in Quran

   References
   “It is He who created the night and the day, and the sun and the moon, all (the celestial bodies) swim along, each in its orbit with its own motion.” (The Noble Quran, 21:33)

   “It is He who made the sun a shining light and the moon a derived light and determined for it phases – that you may know the number of years and account [of time]. Allah has not created this except in truth. He details the signs for a people who know” (The Noble Quran, 10:5)

   “It is not allowable for the sun to reach the moon, nor does the night overtake the day, but each, in an orbit, is swimming.” (The Noble Quran,36:40)

   “And it is We Who have constructed the heaven with might, and verily, it is We Who are steadily expanding it.” (The Noble Quran, 51:47)

   “And the sun runs his course for a period determined for him: that is the decree of (Him), the Exalted in Might, the All-Knowing.” (The Noble Quran,36:38)

   There are many things mentioned in Quran which doesn`t go against established science.

   Reply

10. Then why you brought Darwin here, look science is not the medium to measure what is right and what is wrong especially when it comes to morality,spirituality. Science is after-all humans knowledge about this universe,nature,etc. Science is not god. It is human effort to learn how god created this world.

    Since you agreed with me that scientific beliefs change then why you try to defend yourself against islam using science as cover. Actually islam is so powerful that no other religion has guts t face it. So they bring science, but they don`t know many scientific facts are against their religion but not a single scientific fact is against Islam. Look, here I am talking about scientific facts, not scientific theory,assumption,hypothesis…

    Yes, you are right, science is flexible, but Quran is not because Quran is the word of Allah, the creator of heavens and earth.

    hahha you are comparing mosque with hospital, Allah never told us to go to mosque to cure diseases, mosque has other benefits, its where people gather, they share their thoughts, they meet new people, whether black or white, Indians or Africans, Americans or Pakistani stand in one row and perform namaz…it eliminates racism from people. Is there any scientific medicine which cures racism??

    Even Allah in Quran says that he has given medicinal plants which are beneficial for us, he never said goto mosque and there you will find those plants. My advice to you that you first learn what is the purpose of mosque?

    Science is flexible, now suppose a muslim left Islam in those days believing sun is stationary as science of that time said so..but islam said opposite, it said sun is not stationary but rotates about it`s own axis, today we know this fact, Quran said this 1400 years ago…now suppose X no. of people died believing that. Now do you consider those people fools??
    Admin, you mark my word, not a single scientific fact is against Quran and more science will advance, Quran will get even clearer to people.

    Let me add one more thing, today we know this universe is expanding, but Quran said this in 1400 years ago. Here we see this verse from Quran.

    “And it is We who have constructed the heaven with might, and verily, it is We who are steadily expanding it.”
    (The Noble Qur’an, 51:47)

    Before the invention of the telescope in 1608, man could do little more than wonder about the origin of the universe. (Courtesy: NASA)

    In 1916, Albert Einstein formulated his General Theory of Relativity that indicated that the universe must be either expanding or contracting. Confirmation of the expanding-universe theory finally came in 1929 in the hands of the well known American astronomer Edwin Hubble.

    By observing redshifts[2] in the light wavelengths emitted by galaxies, Hubble found that galaxies were not fixed in their position; instead, they were actually moving away from us with speeds proportional to their distance from earth (Hubble’s Law). The only explanation for this observation was that the universe had to be expanding. Hubble’s discovery is regarded as one of the greatest in the history of astronomy. In 1929, he published the velocity-time relation which is the basis of modern cosmology. In the years to come, with further observations, the expanding-universe theory was accepted by scientists and astronomers alike.

    Yet, astonishingly well before telescopes were even invented and well before Hubble published his Law, Prophet Muhammad used to recite a verse of the Quran to his companions that ultimately stated that the universe is expanding.

    “And the heaven We created with might, and indeed We are (its) expander.” (Quran 51:47)

    At the time of the revelation of the Quran, the word “space” was not known, and people used the word “heaven” to refer to what lies above the Earth. In the above verse, the word “heaven” is referring to space and the known universe. The verse points out that space, and thus the universe, happens to be expanding, just as Hubble’s Law states.

    That the Quran mentioned such a fact centuries before the invention of the first telescope, at a time when there was primitive knowledge in science, is considered remarkable. This is more so considering that, like many people in his time, Prophet Muhammad happened to be illiterate and simply could not have been aware of such facts by himself. Could it be that he had truly received divine revelation from the Creator and Originator of the universe?

    Quran is the word of the creator of world,universe, we call that creator by name like Allah,God,Bhagwan,Waheguru,Yahweh,etc.

    Reply

11. On your point, “what is right and what is wrong”, science and faith are at different extreme. In science, every thing could be questioned and assessed as right or wrong. When comes to faith, there is nothing to question, one has to accept it as 100% truth, what ever that faith is. Unfortunately, millions have been killed to prove whose faith/God is right. Fortunately, science is saving millions and improving quality of life for all.

    You may not like Darwin’s theory but you like Muhammad’s theories. Others may not find any justification in facts like this world was created in 2+4 days, God talked to Mohammed, polygamy, talaak, there will be a J-Day, God will give all men big breast women, all non-Wahhabi and non-Sunni will get Hell Fire, etc. Every faith has its own limitation but if Islam works for you, we are happy.

    Every day, science is improving. Contrary to that, every day, more and more people becoming atheists.

    Agree to you, when it comes to spirituality and peace of mind, faith is a superior tool over science. Ideally, it is good to take best from science and faith. On the matter of faith, it would be good if people learn to respect others faith; live and let others live. Please be a pluralist!

    Reply

12. More people have died because of science than of religious conflict, if you don`t know then do a research..thousands of people died in Japan not because of Bible`s pages but because of Nuclear fission. Now by science here I meant to say use of science to kill people with comparison to killing of people because of their different faith.

    ///Fortunately, science is saving millions and improving quality of life for all. /////
    —Increase in CO2, methane gas,etc…global warming..effect of technologies on human body..effect of computer,mobile,tablet on human eye sight..huh..list is long..

    I didn`t say I dislike Darwin`s theory, I said there were many theories which we today laugh at and i have given example above earlier.

    Admin, coming to world was created in 6 days, now for god to create world he can take 600 days or 60 days or 6 days..for him it is nothing..then why you are so worried about how much time it took god to create earth and and rest of universe.

    Then you said God talked to Muhammad(pbuh), god can talk to anyone, god like Muhammad so he talked with him, is it impossible for god to talk with Muhammad when we know god is the manager of impossible,miracle.

    Admin, on Polygamy, I would like to ask you a two question:
    (1) Is Polygamy compulsory for muslim men?
    (2) What is your absolute solution on a population where women out number men?

    #Talaq,
    one one hand you advice couple how to proceed on Divorce on the other hand you have problems with Talaq, while we know the English of the Arabic word Talaq(طلاق) is Divorce.

    #There will be J-day.
    Since both of us cannot produce evidence on Judgement day, then how come you say there will be no judgement day. Also can you provide here logical evidence of judgement day being a false concept.

    ///God will give all men big breast women, all non-Wahhabi and non-Sunni will get Hell Fire, etc. ///

    Why won`t god give big breast women, is it impossible for god to produce big-breast women. If big breast doesn`t matter then why women are running after plastic surgery to enlarge breast? Why there are adds every where on how to enlarge breast? Even there also your science is playing a role from enlarging breast to killing innocent human being.

    Who said all Non-wahabi,Non-sunni will get hell fire or did you just invent this theory?

    Quran is clearly against creating sect and Quran is very clear about who will go to heaven and who will go to hell.

    “Some of those who have divided their religion into different sects are not your concern. Their affairs are in the hands of God Who will show them all that they have done.“ [The Noble Quran Chapter 6 :Verse 159]

    You are saying be a pluralist, what you mean by that? plural in sense of god or in sense of culture?

    Reply

13. Oh yes, let us correct, “science and religions have killed many people. Both are good provided people don’t use it wrong way”. This is a good time to bring in pluralism discussion.

    If you put in Google for pluralism, this is the first on the list “Pluralism … denotes a diversity of views and stands rather than a single approach or method of …” This is what we meant. If you say Shias are not Muslims, that is your intolerant way looking at the world. Remember that you had no major interest in religion just a few years in past. Even today, you are not perfoming namaz 5 times/day. Someone may insult you by saying you are not a true Muslim, why? Be proud of newly found interest in Islam, however, don’t be so fanatic that one day you go on crusade hurting (non-believer) others. Let Shia do what they wish and Hindu do what they wish; as far as they are not hurting others. Live and let other live.

    Agree, Darwin and God created World in 2+4 days are all theories. Let it rest there.

    On “God talked to Muhammad”, similarly, in the Lage Raho Munna Bhai movie, Gandhiji talked to Munna Bhai many times. It could be truth or hallucinations. Again, this is a theory Muslims wish to believe and we don’t have any problem with it.

    On Polygamy, No it is not compulsory but is allowed legally to Muslims in India. This is truth and not a theory. This is your stupid argument, “What is your absolute solution on a population where women out number men?” This is not an issue in India today but still polygamy is legal, why?

    Talaq quick divorce is male chauvinist practice. We are sure today educated Muslim girls hate this practice.

    On big breast women, are the breasts going to be firm, and with pink nipple? We do not know but how many such virgins Muslim men will get on J-day? What will happen to women/girls with normal breast? These are certainly sexual enticements.

    On “Quran … who will go to hell”, do you still believe Mahatma Gandhi and Mother Teresa will go to heaven? How about Shias? Jews?

    Reply

14. On “but it has given rights to defend ourselves”, we hope you don’t go on crusade killing people. You are a good man and wish you be little more tolerant to others and others practices.

    On your point “liberates both male and female from their evil life partners”, can wife give talaak to his husband in Islam?

    Jews don’t believe in the J-Day.

    Is any other religion offer sexual enticement to male followers like Islam do?

    Reply

15. ///On “but it has given rights to defend ourselves”, we hope you don’t go on crusade killing people. ///

    Admin, defending is not going out and killing people, defend does not mean killing, if you attack our religion through pen, we will defend it by pen, if you use arms, we will use arms to defend.
    Are you saying they will attack us first? Are you aware of any evil plan of non-muslim enemies?

    ////You are a good man and wish you be little more tolerant to others and others practices.////

    I have never created any comment intentionally against another community on this site from my side, all I did is replied to you peoples allegations on islam and muslim and showed you mirror. Just look at this website, most of comments are anti-islamic. Are you saying I don`t have right to say that what others are saying about Islam are incorrect? don`t I have the right to defend my religion?

    ///On your point “liberates both male and female from their evil life partners”, can wife give talaak to his husband in Islam?///
    Yes, she can.

    ///Jews don’t believe in the J-Day.///
    who told you.

    ///Is any other religion offer sexual enticement to male followers like Islam do?///
    All major religions like Islam,Christianity.

    Reply

16. mac, main problem with others for your belief is exclusivity. You are out proving that only Muhammad’s statements are truth while Christians are wrong in believing Jesus as a Son of God, Jews are wrong because they are not following Muhammad, Hindus are wrong praying to multiple Gods, Shia are wrong because they follow Ali, etc. You believe what you wish to and let others follow their own faith.

    Reply

17. Admin, where did we started? LOL 🙂 every-time you divert the topic instead of replying.

    BTW I am not only saying that Jesus is not god, even Jesus(pbuh) never said he is god or worship him, he always talked about his father. This is problem with Christianity what they want to believe. Why you ask me?

    Their Bible also speaks against their Christian belief of trinity. Why you are asking me?

    ///You believe what you wish to and let others follow their own faith./////
    When did I force others to leave their religion. It is your website which is doing anti-islamic work and you blaming me. I am only giving you answers to your allegations on Islam. We have not yet started asking questions on other religion. More than 60,000 books were written on Muhammad pbuh but one book, written by muslim on Jesus angered the so called freedom loving christian world. Why? It shows the intolerance of non-Muslims. They like to criticize islam,muslim, ridicule muslim and when Muslims reply, then they bring they topic of tolerance but they do behind the banner of freedom of speech. HYPOCRITES.

    Reply

18. That is exactly what we are saying. You see problems with every one, but when comes to Islam, it is 100% pure and perfect. You guys are idolizing Muhammad out of proportion. Remove Mohammad and only let Allah (or Isvar. Father God, etc) be only important. What Allah, that created billions of galaxies, cares about if you show your back 5 times a day or not? Before Mohammad, people were praying in the direction of Jerusalem, Mohammad, in exile in Medina in 622, change his goal to Kaaba and now you are bowing to Kaaba. Muhammad had 11 wives, but he limit it all you to 4. If you see it or not, it is all Muhammad, Muhammad, and Muhammad. Again, we do not have problem you idolizing Muhammad, but let others do what they wish.

    Reply